CFD Companies

A Bad Atheist's Perspective on BRI or Ethically Conscious Investing (ECI)

A Covert Operation

Zachary W. Covert
President of Second, Third and 53rd Chances

CFD Companies

BRI / ECI Presentation Goals

CFD Companies
Mugshot photo
CFD Companies
Mugshot photo, alternate crop
CFD Companies

Understand
The Consumers

Sources: Philip J. Cook, Paying the Tab (Princeton University Press), analysis of NIAAA-funded NESARC survey data — reported in The Washington Post and Smithsonian. Foster et al. 2021 (UNC/Johns Hopkins/BU, NIAAA-funded), 2016 data — sph.unc.edu. NIAAA, "Mental Health Issues: Alcohol Use Disorder and Common Co-occurring Conditions" — niaaa.nih.gov. NESARC comorbidity analysis — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov. The bipolar/comorbidity bullets are prevalence rates (how much more likely a diagnosed group is to have AUD), not a share of total alcohol sales.
CFD Companies

Understand
The Damage

Sources: CDC, alcohol-attributable deaths (2020-2022 est., most recent available) — niaaa.nih.gov. Opioid/fentanyl overdose totals, CDC/NIDA 2023 — nida.nih.gov. Sacks et al., "2010 National and State Costs of Excessive Alcohol Consumption," CDC/Am J Prev Medpubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov. Foster et al. 2021 (UNC/Johns Hopkins/BU, NIAAA-funded) — sph.unc.edu. Esser et al., CDC/JAMA Network Open, 2022 — jamanetwork.com.
CFD Companies

Math
Isn't that a capital loss?

Sources: TTB (Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau), Statistical Release: Tax Collections, FY2023. Figure corroborated via Congressional Research Service, "Alcohol Excise Taxes: An Overview," R48181 (Sept. 2024) — congress.gov.
CFD Companies

Evidence is in the ads

AB InBev "Merry Christmas" print ad — a beer glass with foam styled as a Santa hat
Source: "Merry Christmas," InBev, agency Draft FCB Ulka (New Delhi, India), December 2008 — adsoftheworld.com.
CFD Companies

Evidence is in the ads

Fireball Adult Trick-or-Treat bag
Source: advertisinglaw.fkks.com.
CFD Companies

Evidence is in the ads

Source: youtube.com.
CFD Companies

The Default Option Isn't Neutral

1

Ownership

Stock owners are rewarded by participating in the profit of companies.

2

A Vote of Confidence

Most publicly traded companies structure executive compensation with stock packages and additional stock options. This gives leadership a vested interest in the company's profit and growth — but it also means that buying the stock is, in effect, a vote of confidence in that leadership.

3

Index and Broad Market Funds Fund the Defense

Vanguard, BlackRock, and State Street — the "Big Three" — are the largest shareholder in ~88% of S&P 500 companies, holding ~22.2% of S&P 500 market value (up from 13.5% in 2008) — and cast about one-quarter of all votes at S&P 500 annual meetings, voting almost as a single bloc. These asset managers vote 98.7% of the time according to the recommendations of executive leadership.

Sources: Bebchuk & Hirst, "The Specter of the Giant Three," NBER WP 25914 — nber.org. Pearl Meyer 2025 S&P 500 proxy analysis (equity-heavy exec pay) — pearlmeyer.com. Big Three's 98.7% management-support rate: Morningstar, "US Proxy-Voting Trends: 2025 in Review" (Lindsey Stewart) — morningstar.com.

So what can we really do?

Talk About Porn

obviously

CFD Companies

Understand
The Consumer

Sources: Grubbs et al., "Self-reported addiction to pornography in a nationally representative sample," Journal of Behavioral Addictions, 2019 (N=2,075) — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov. De Roos & Willkomm, "Crossing the Line: Factors Associated With Escalating Pornography Use," Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 2026 (N=228) — journals.sagepub.com. Network-analysis escalation/tolerance study, Addictive Behaviors (N=2,300, US/UK) — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov. Note: the 2026 study's self-reported rate of deliberate CSAM searching (under 1%) was removed from this slide as likely understated — see slide 15's victim counts and slide 16's 706,000-flagged-video count for scale drawn from records rather than self-report.
CFD Companies

Understand
The Damage

The Pornhub Story

Sources: EAU (European Association of Urology) 2020 Congress study, N=3,267 — urotoday.com. Women's pressure/performance claim: qualitative study, Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy, 2024 (N=30 women, UK/Greece) — tandfonline.com — small sample, treat as illustrative of a documented pattern, not a population-wide percentage. "1 in 3" stat: Wheatley Institute, National Couples and Pornography Survey, 2021 — wheatley.byu.edu. Newsweek, "Pornhub Is Still a Crime Scene, Even After Its Rebrand" — newsweek.com (opinion piece; underlying primary source for the ~300/25-lawsuits figure not independently confirmed). Bloomberg Law, "Second Pornhub Sex-Trafficking Case Certified as Class Action," Dec 2023 — news.bloomberglaw.com. TopClassActions, on Doe No. 1, et al. v. MG Freesites LTD, et al., N.D. Ala. Case No. 7:21-cv-00220 — topclassactions.com.
CFD Companies

Understand
The Math

Sources: Nicholas Kristof, "The Children of Pornhub," New York Times, Dec 4, 2020 — nytimes.com (mirror). Washington Examiner, on unsealed internal court documents — washingtonexaminer.com. WRAL/AP, on the post-investigation purge — wral.com.
CFD Companies

The Takedown

Sources: Nicholas Kristof, "The Children of Pornhub," New York Times, Dec 4, 2020 — nytimes.com (mirror). Michelle Celarier, "Bill Ackman Sent a Text to the CEO of Mastercard" — michellecelarier.com. Fortune, Aug 2, 2022 — fortune.com. CNN, Dec 2020 (Discover) — cnn.com. CNBC, Aug 4 2022 (TrafficJunky) — cnbc.com. Pershing Square Holdings 2020 Annual Report — pershingsquareholdings.com.
CFD Companies

The Aftermath After Report

~3.0%

High-Risk Merchant Processor

~$13.8M of $460M (2018) — the largest cut, pricing in chargeback and legal risk

~1.85%

Card-Issuing Bank

~$8.5M of $460M — standard interchange, not elevated just because the merchant is high-risk

0.13-0.15%

Visa / Mastercard

Just $598K-$690K — their own network fee is a sliver of the total

Conventional thinking says go after the issuing banks. That's not what Ackman did.

The 3-way revenue split above is this author's own worked example, applying published industry rate ranges (high-risk merchant processing: 4-7%+; standard interchange: 1.5-3.5%; Visa/Mastercard network assessment fee: 0.13-0.15%) to MindGeek's disclosed 2018 revenue. Checked specifically for a self-dealing angle (major advertisers or Visa/MC's own products appearing within TrafficJunky) — found none; the one "major brand" lead (Wish) was a fabricated relationship Wish itself denied. Sources: Semafor, "Inside Pornhub's Finances," 2023 (2018 revenue figure) — semafor.com. Merchant Cost Consulting, on interchange vs. assessment fees — merchantcostconsulting.com.
CFD Companies

"Start by doing what's necessary; then do what's possible; and suddenly you are doing the impossible."

— Francis of Assisi

[ CFD tagline goes here ]
CFD Companies

Example Language

CFD Companies

"God doesn't protect us from knives sweetheart. That's why God gave us other people."

Anxious People — Fredrik Backman

This Has Been a Presentation of Covert Information

Your time and future discretion are appreciated